Algonquin: Hold Your Horses Now (NYSE:AQN)

Algonquin Power & Utilities Corp. (NYSE:AQN) has outperformed the S&P 500 (SPX) (SPY) significantly since our previous update in January. We argued back then that dividend investors likely bailed out after the company announced its 40% dividend cut. However, we also discussed why AQN's price action suggests the market had likely priced it in, forcing these income investors to flee at the lows.

Accordingly, AQN recovered more than 25% from its December lows (in price-performance terms) through this week's highs, stunning bearish investors. We believe it's essential for investors to assess why we highlighted its reward/risk was attractive back in late December and January, despite the massive pessimism.

With a 10Y total return CAGR of 5.8%, the recovery is significant for these bottom-fishers who correctly anticipated a mean-reversion opportunity.

Algonquin's FQ4 release was better than expected. However, investors should note that its adjusted EPS of $0.22 (Vs. Q3's $0.11) was lifted by 'gains on asset sales in the Renewable Energy Group.'

Accordingly, Algonquin posted $277M in cash proceeds on the sale of its US facilities and C$108.6M on its Blue Hill Wind Facility (resulting in about $316M in total proceeds). As such, the company delivered a gain on disposition of $62.8M.

Notably, the company maintains that it's on track to record asset sales of $1B in 2023. However, investors should note the estimated gains/losses on disposition in 2023 are not included in its midpoint adjusted EPS guidance of $0.58 for FY23.

Moreover, its midpoint guidance indicates that Algonquin anticipates a 16% YoY decline in its adjusted EPS relative to last year's $0.69 metric. With that in mind, we believe the company's asset recycling strategy will remain an ongoing component of its business strategy, which could lead to volatility in its adjusted EPS trajectory.

Algonquin recorded total assets of more than $17B as of the end of 2022. Hence, the company believes it has significant opportunities to unlock the value of its assets moving ahead. CEO Arun Banskota articulated:

[We have] over $17 billion worth of assets in our portfolio, the $1 billion [asset sales] taken in context is a fairly small amount. We have quite a number of different optionalities for that $1 billion of proceeds. As you know, we just announced in the fourth quarter, the renewable asset sell-down with proceeds in the range of $316 million. That is part of our ongoing strategy on the renewable side of the business. And with our acquisitive history over the many years, we certainly have a number of optionalities to get to that $1 billion, and we certainly will provide you more color with time. (Algonquin FQ4'22 earnings call)

Importantly, management highlighted that investors must wait until April 26 to get clarity over its acquisition of Kentucky Power Company. The company did not offer additional guidance over how the regulatory approval would pan out, even though it filed a new application with the FERC on February 15. Despite that, its acquisition is still 'subject to the satisfaction or waiver of certain conditions precedent.'

For investors, what do they need to consider? Note that the company highlighted that its estimated CapEx is about $3.6B for 2023, including the $2.6B acquisition of Kentucky Power.

Management articulated that the company still 'has more growth opportunities on both the regulated and renewable sides of the business,' even if the approval was not granted.

However, we believe the uncertainty could keep dip buyers from adding more positions from here after a remarkable recovery from its December/January lows, normalizing its valuation.

AQN bottom-fishers astutely ignored the massive pessimism at the end of last year, as it formed a bear trap or false downside breakdown. It then staged an impressive recovery over the past three months, as seen in AQN's long-term chart above.

Its valuation has also normalized. Accordingly, AQN's NTM EBITDA multiple of 11.2x is in line with its peers' median of 11.3x (according to S&P Cap IQ). Also, with the cut in its dividend, its NTM dividend yield of 5.5% is much less attractive now.

AQN blended fair value estimates (InvestingPro)

Its blended fair value estimates suggest a potential 16% undervaluation. However, we assessed that its near-term upside is likely reflected in its mean reversion.

Given significant uncertainty over its pending acquisition and business strategy, we urge investors to account for a higher margin of safety to account for considerable execution risks.

With that in mind, we believe our thesis has played out accordingly and, therefore, is appropriate for investors to consider moving to the sidelines from here.

Rating: Hold (Revised from Buy).

本站仅提供存储服务，所有内容均由用户发布，如发现有害或侵权内容，请点击举报。